Get Permission Muneeb U shaban: A comparative study to assess the effectiveness of structured teaching program on knowledge regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among BSc nursing 2nd year and BSc nursing 3rd year students in selected nursing colleges of Patiala, Punjab


Introduction

Bedridden patient is a patient that has to stay in bed for a long period of time. Such patient might quickly develop serious complications that are not directly linked with the reason why he has to stay in bed. Most of those complications can be very easily prevented using simple exercises and teaching the patient or the caretaker. The reason why a patient has to stay in bed can be multiple trauma, fracture of the spine, paralysis, severe disease, coma, surgery, head injury etc. The most common complications of bedridden patients are muscle weakness/atrophy, pressure sores (bed ulcerations), respiratory problems (lung infection), Blood circulation problems, bone demineralization. 1 The skin has multiple layers of ectodermic tissue and guards the underlying muscles, bones, ligaments and internal organs. Because it interfaces with the environment, skin plays a key immunity role in protecting the body against pathogens and excessive water loss.2 The important functions of the skin are to protecting the underlying tissue and serve as a surface barrier to the external environment, barrier against invasion of bacteria and viruses and excessive water loss, fat insulates the body and provides protection from trauma, sensory perception for external stimuli, heat regulation, homeostasis by fluid and electrolyte balance, synthesis of vitamin D.3 Impaired skin integrity is not normally a problem in healthy people but it is a threat to the elderly clients who have restricted mobility or chronic illness.4 The longer the pressure lasts, the greater is the risk of skin breakdown and development of pressure ulcer.5

The purpose of the study was to assess and compare knowledge regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among B.Sc. 2nd year and B.Sc. 3rd year nursing students in selected colleges of Patiala Punjab. Bedridden patient is a patient that has to stay in bed for a long period of time. Such patient might quickly develop serious complications that are not directly linked with the reason why he has to stay in bed. A pressure ulcer is a localized injury to the skin or underlying tissue usually occurs over a bony prominence, as a result of unrelieved pressure or pressure in combination with shear.6

Pressure ulcers are caused by unrelieved pressure applied with great force (shear) over a short period or less force (friction) over a long period that disrupts blood supply to the capillary network, impeding blood flow and depriving tissue of oxygen and nutrients Pressure ulcers are a serious health issue for patients in all kinds of health care settings and even at home thus reduction of pressure ulcer prevalence in long- term care (LTC) is a Healthy people 2010

initiative. In fact, Florence Nightingale in 1859 wrote, ―If he has a bedsore, it‘s generally not the fault of the disease, but of the nursing. The incidence varies from 0.4% to 38% in hospitals and 2.2%–23% in long-term care settings. Bedsores are one of the most costly and physically debilitating complications. Pressure ulcers (PrUs) affect approximately 2.5 million patients and account for 60,000 deaths annually. They are associated with an additional annual cost of $43,000 per related hospital stay and a total cost to the US health care system as high as $25 billion. 7 Butcher (2012), stated that immobility is widely documented in the literature as a cause of increased mortality and complications. Immobilized patients are at greater risk for skin breakdown and delayed wound healing. The musculoskeletal system is severely affected by immobility and prolonged bed rest. Prolonged bed rest and immobilization inevitably lead to complications. Such complications are much easier to prevent than to treat. 8 In the intensive care unit (ICU), patients have multiple factors that increase the risk of pressure ulcers developing. Typically the patient has respiratory equipment, urinary catheters, sequential compression devices, multiple intravenous catheters, and the infusion of vasoactive agents for hypotension that may contribute to inability to turn patients and increase the risk of pressure ulcer development.9

Need for the Study

“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure”

Preventing pressure ulcers can save the health service, millions of pounds and improve patient care. Pressure ulcers are common problem in nursing practice and entail great expenses for the patients as well as for the health care services. Despite technologic and preventive advances in recent years, the incidence of pressure ulcers in acute care remains unacceptably high.

The prevalence of pressure ulcer development is highest among the older adult population and it has been estimated that 70 percent of pressure ulcers occur in patients older than 70 years of age. 95 percent of pressure ulcers develop on the lower part of the body; 65 percent develop in the pelvic area and 30 percent develop on the lower limbs. The average estimated annual cost of treating a pressure ulcer ranges from $5000 to $60,000. This results in a cost to the U.S. health care system of about $8.5 billion annually. In the older adult population, the risk of death from a pressure ulcer increases fourfold. Nurses are often blamed for pressure ulcers as they are seen as a failure of nursing care, most pressure ulcers can be prevented if there is an active plan for their prevention. 10 A study conducted on prevalence of pressure ulcers in hospitalized patients in India. A total of 445 patients hospitalized in medical and surgical wards were examined in a single day for the number, site and grade of pressure ulcers. Hemoglobin, serum albumin and blood sugar levels of patients with pressure ulcers were recorded. The result was the prevalence of pressure ulcers was high (4.94%). Anemia, malnutrition and diabetes were important risk factors, while morbidity due to pressure ulcers in long-stay wards, such as neurology, was exceptionally high (40.9%).

Table 1

Frequency and percentage distribution of socio-demographic variables among B.Sc. nursing 2nd year and B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students in selected nursing colleges of Patiala, Punjab N=60

Socio-demographic variables

B.Sc. nursing 2nd year Frequency (n=30)

B.Sc. nursing 2nd year Percentage (%)

B.Sc. nursing 3rd year Frequency (n=30)

B.Sc. nursing 3rd year Percentage (%)

Age(in years)

18 Years

6

20.0%

0

0.0%

19 Years

20

66.7%

6

20.0%

20 Years

3

10.0%

21

70.0%

21 Years

1

3.3%

3

10.0%

Gender

Male

8

26.7%

13

43.3%

Female

22

73.3%

17

56.7%

Educational Qualification

B.Sc. (nursing) 2nd year

30

100.0%

0

0.0%

B.Sc. (nursing) 3rd year

0

0.0%

30

100.0%

Clinical Posting

Medical ward

9

30.0%

8

26.7%

Surgical ward

11

36.7%

5

16.7%

Orthopedic ward

6

20.0%

9

30.0%

Intensive care unit

4

13.3%

8

26.7%

Source of information regarding prevention of pressure ulcers

Clinical instructors

26

86.7%

26

86.7%

College mates

1

3.3%

1

3.3%

Mass media

2

6.7%

1

3.3%

Other

1

3.3%

2

6.7%

Table 2

Comparison of distribution of Frequency and Percentage between Pre-test and Post-test Knowledge Score regarding the effectiveness of structured teaching program on knowledge regarding prevention of pressure ulcersamong B.Sc.nursing 2nd year and B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students

Criteria Measure of Pre-Test Versus Post-Test Knowledge Score

Score Level

Pre-test

Pre-test

Post-test

Post-test

BSc nursing 2nd year

BSc nursing 3rd year

BSc nursing 2nd year

BSc nursing 3rd year

Freq

%

Freq

%

Freq

%

Freq

%

Adequate 67-100%(21-30)

0

0%

0

0%

28

93.3%

26

86.7%

Moderate 34-66%(11-20)

6

20%

3

10%

2

6.7%

4

13.3%

Inadequate ≤33%(0-10)

24

80%

27

90%

0

0%

0

0%

Maximum=30 Minimum =0

Figure 1

Bar Diagram showing Comparison of Pre-test and Post-test Knowledge Score regarding the effectiveness of structured teaching program on knowledge regarding prevention of pressure ulcers between B.Sc. nursing 2nd year versus B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/fb065379-01d4-470d-bbfe-10c100b4a8efimage1.png
Table 3

Association of Post-test Score regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students in selected nursing colleges of Patiala, Punjab with their selected socio-demographic variables

Demographic Variables

Level of Scores

Association of KNOWLEDGE Score with Demographic variables (Post KNOWLEDGE) BSc 3rd Students

Variables

Options

Inadequate

Moderate

Adequate

Chi Test

P Value

df

Table Value

Result

Age ( in years)

18 Years

0

0

0

1.360

0.507

2

5.991

Not Significant

19 Years

0

1

5

20 Years

0

2

19

21 Years

0

1

2

Gender

Male

0

3

10

1.885

0.170

1

3.841

Not Significant

Female

0

1

16

Educational Qualification

B.Sc. (nursing) 2nd year

0

0

0

NA

B.Sc. (nursing) 3rd year

0

4

26

Clinical Posting

Medical ward

0

1

7

4.471

0.215

3

7.815

Not Significant

Surgical surgical ward

0

2

3

Orthopedic ward

0

0

9

Intensive care unit

0

1

7

Source of information regarding prevention of pressure ulcers

Clinical instructors

0

4

22

0.710

0.871

3

7.815

Not Significant

College mates

0

0

1

Mass media

0

0

1

Other

0

0

2

Objectives

  1. To assess the pre-test knowledge score regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among BSc nursing 2nd year and BSc nursing 3rd year students in selected nursing colleges of Patiala, Punjab.

  2. To plan and implement structured teaching program regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among BSc nursing 2nd year and BSc nursing 3rd year students in selected nursing colleges of Patiala, Punjab.

  3. To evaluate the post-test knowledge score regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among BSc nursing 2nd year and BSc nursing 3rd year students in selected nursing colleges of Patiala, Punjab.

  4. To compare the pre-test and post-test knowledge score regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among BSc nursing 2nd year and BSc nursing 3rd year students in selected nursing colleges of Patiala, Punjab.

  5. To find out the association between pre-test knowledge score regarding prevention of pressure ulcers with their socio demographic variables.

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

Inclusion criteria

The study included B.Sc. nursing 2nd year and B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students: -

  1. B.Sc. nursing 2nd year and B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students of selected nursing colleges of Patiala Punjab.

  2. Are willing to participate in the research study.

  3. Are available at the time of study Data Collection.

Exclusion criteria

  1. The study excluded nursing students who were not: -

  2. Willing to participate in the study.

  3. Available at the time of study Data Collection

Selection and Developmnt of Tool

Research tool consists of two (2) sections

  1. Section A- Socio-demographic variables.

  2. Section B- Multiple choice self-structured knowledge questions regarding prevention of Pressure Ulcers.

Development of Structured Knowledge Questionnaire

A self-structured knowledge questionnaire was prepared for assessing the knowledge regarding prevention regarding prevention of pressure ulcers among B.Sc. nursing 2nd year and B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students. The tool was developed after the extensive review of research and non-research literature, seeking the opinion of experts and guides, formal and non-formal discussions with the peer group and investigators professional experience.

A blue print was prepared by specifying the domains of areas. Details of the blue print are shown in table 1. Item writing was done after preparing the blue print specifying the domains of objectives (knowledge, comprehension, and application).

Conclusion

The study depicts the Pre-test Knowledge Score comparison revealed that in the B.Sc. nursing 2nd year students, majority of students 24(80%) had Inadequate knowledge and 6(20%) had Moderate knowledge but none of them had Adequate knowledge. Whereas in the B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students, majority of students 27(90%) had Inadequate knowledge and 3(10%) had Moderate knowledge but none of them had Adequate knowledge.

Post-test Knowledge Score comparison revealed that in the B.Sc. nursing 2nd year students, majority of students 28(93.3%) had Adequate knowledge and 2(6.7%) had Moderate knowledge but none of them had Inadequate knowledge. Whereas in the B.Sc. nursing 3rd year students, majority of students 26(86.7%) had Inadequate knowledge and 4(13.3%) had Moderate knowledge but none of them had Inadequate knowledge.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

Training of Physiotherapists and Doctors in Hospitalshttps://static.aminer.org/pdf/PDF/000/355/038/therapyofbedriddenpatients.pdf

2 

3 

LL Sharon MH Margaret RD Shannon GO Patrica B Linda Medical-Surgical Nursing: Assessment and Management of Clinical Problems1st10th20161776

4 

B Kozier G Erb K Blias Fundamentals of nursing concepts, process and practicePearson Education2008787

5 

SL Williams DP Hopper R Rezaie Understanding Medical-Surgical Nursing183rdF.A. Davis Company2005927

6 

E Bethell incidence and prevalence data: can we ensure greater accuracyJ wound care20021182858

7 

R Allman PS Goode N Burst AA Bartolucci DR Thomas Pressure ulcers,hospital complications, and disease severity:impact on hospital costs and length of stayAdv Wound Care19991212230

8 

CH Lyder EA Ayello Hughes RG Patient Safety and Quality: An Evidence-Based Handbook for NursesRockville (MD): Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (US)2008

9 

C Van Gilder S Amlung P Harrison S Meyer Results of the 2008-2009.International Pressure ulcers prevalance survey and three year acute care unit specific analysis. Ostomy Wound Manage200955113555

10 

S M Mosby Lewis M M Heitkemper S R Dirksen Medical Surgical Nursing: Assessment and management of clinical problemsMissouri2004



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 17-10-2023

Accepted : 29-11-2023


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File  


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijpns.2023.026


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 644

PDF Downloaded: 308