Get Permission Lallawmzuali and Dutta: Effectiveness of STP regarding abortion and its consequences


Introduction

According to World Health Organization, Abortion is defined as the expulsion or extraction from its mother of an embryo or fetus weighing 500g or less when it is not capable of independent survival.1

Abortion can be considered as a major problem worldwide.  It is one of the important cause of maternal morbidity and mortality. In some countries, it is legally accepted and in some others not accepted at all for any reason. In India, can be performed on various grounds until 20 weeks of pregnancy. The termination of pregnancies up to 24 weeks will only apply to specific categories of women, as may be prescribed by the central government.2 Abortion may also cause complications like severe haemorrhage, shock, sepsis, uterine perforation, cervical injury, severe anemia, severe infection, renal failure. In late sequelae - infertility, ectopic gestation, increased risk of spontaneous abortion and reduced birth weight. There are two types of abortion: Spontaneous and Induced, Spontaneous abortions, or miscarriages, occur for many reasons, including disease, trauma, genetic defect, or biochemical incompatibility of mother and fetus. Occasionally a fetus dies in the uterus but fails to be expelled, a condition termed a missed abortion.1

Abortion is common and it should be considered part of a broader reproductive health agenda. Unexpected pregnancies in college life become altering the life.3 According to many studies, abortion rate have become very high among young youths. Poverty and lack of awareness are also the deciding factors in early marriages and teenage pregnancies in rural areas, Love affairs at school and teenage elopements are also increasing. The impact of media, especially television, is affecting the child's mind. The access to Internet is another factor. Add to this the lack of proper sex education and parental guidance and it leads to misguided sexual explorations that often results in pregnancy 4. Proper education among the reproductive age group is highly necessary in order to avoid unintended pregnancy leading to abortion.

According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-4) India 2015-16 ASSAM , Among young women age 15-19 in Assam, 14 percent have already begun childbearing, that is, they have already had a live birth or are pregnant with their first child, down from 16 percent in NFHS-3. Less than 5 percent of women age 15-16 years have started childbearing, but this proportion increases sharply to 21 percent among women who are 18 years old and to 32 percent among women who are 19 years old. Young women who had no schooling are more than eight times as likely to have begun childbearing as young women with 12 or more years of schooling.5

Unsafe abortion occurs when a pregnancy is terminated either by persons lacking the necessary skills or in an environment that does not conform to minimal medical standards, or both (WHO). Until unsafe abortion and its consequences are eliminated, complications from unsafe abortion will remain a major cause of maternal mortality and morbidity. Unsafe abortion can be prevented through: comprehensive sexuality education; prevention of unintended pregnancy through use of effective contraception, including emergency contraception; and provision of safe, legal abortion. In addition, deaths and disability from unsafe abortion can be reduced through the timely provision of emergency treatment of complications. 6

Statement of the problem

A study to evaluate the effectiveness of structured teaching programme on knowledge and attitude regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.”

Objectives

  1. To assess the existing knowledge regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students before administering Structured Teaching Programme in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.

  2. To assess the attitude regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.

  3. To evaluate the effectiveness of structured teaching programme on abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.

  4. To determine the association between pre-test knowledge score and selected demographic variables of undergraduate students in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.To determine the association between pre-test attitude score and selected demographic variables of undergraduate students in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.

Hypotheses (the hypotheses were tested at 0 05 level of significance

  1. H1: There is significant difference between the pre-test and post test knowledge scores among undergraduate students regarding abortion and its consequences.

  2. H2: There is significant association between pre-test knowledge score and selected demographic variables of undergraduate students in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.

  3. H3: There is significant association between pre-test attitude score and selected demographic variables of undergraduate students in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.

Material and Methods

Research approach

Quantitative research approach.

Research design

Pre-experimental one group pre-test, post-test design

Setting of the study

The setting for the study was conducted in 3 colleges of Guwahati, Assam, as listed below:

  1. Sankar Madhab College of Nursing

  2. Rahman Institute of Nursing and Paramedics Sciences

  3. CPMS College of Nursing

Population

Undergraduate students studying 2nd year B.Sc Nursing in different selected Nursing Colleges of Guwahati , Assam.

Sample and sample size

100 undergraduate students who are pursuing second year b.sc nursing course in selected colleges of Guwahati, Assam.

Sampling techniques

Non probability consecutive sampling technique.

Sampling criteria

Inclusion criteria

  1. Undergraduate female students.

  2. Undergraduate students both married and unmarried.

  3. Participants who are willing to participate

Exclusion criteria

College students who are sick at the time of data collection.

Variables

The variables for the present study are:

  1. Demographic variable: Age, religion, educational status of mother, educational status of father, occupation of mother, occupation of father, type of family , area of residence, sources of information regarding abortion and its consequences.

  2. Dependent variable: Knowledge and attitude of undergraduate college students regarding the abortion and its consequences.

  3. Independent variable: Structured teaching program on abortion and its consequences.

Development of the tool

In the attempt to assess the knowledge and attitude regarding abortion and its consequences among the undergraduate students in selected colleges of guwahati , assam, tools were prepared in the form of self - administered structured questionnaire and 5-point likert scale.

Description of the tool

The study tool consist of 4 sections:

Section I: Demographic proforma

Demographic Proforma was used to collect the background information. It includes Demographic variables like age, - Age, religion, educational status of mother, educational status of father, occupation of mother, occupation of father, type of family , area of residence, sources of information regarding abortion and its consequences.

Section II: Self- administered structured questionnaire

It was used to assess the knowledge regarding abortion and its consequences among the under graduate students.There are 20 items and all the items were multiple choice question. The items are prepared as per the following heading:

  1. Definition and causes of abortion

  2. Types of abortion

  3. Medical termination of Pregnancy Act

  4. Methods of abortion

  5. Consequences of abortion

  6. Prevention and control of unsafe abortion

  7. Recommendations for someone considering an abortion

Scoring and interpretation

The scoring pattern adopted was 1 mark for correct answer and 0 for wrong answer, maximum score was 20. The knowledge score were divided into 3 areas.

  1. Inadequate Knowledge (0-7)

  2. Moderately adequate knowledge (8-14)

  3. Adequate Knowledge (15-20)

Section III: 5-Point likert scale

There are 10 items, 5 items are positive statement and 5 items are negative statement to assess attitude regarding abortion and its consequences. Scoring for Positive statement is 5,4,3,2,1 from strongly agree to strongly disagree and reversed score from strongly agree to strongly disagree as 1,2,3,4,5 for Negative Statement. The attitude score were divided in 2 areas:

  1. Favourable attitude = 31 & above

  2. Unfavourable attitude = Below 31

Section IV: Structured teaching programme

The Structured teaching Programme on abortion and its consequences was developed for the undergraduate students as it was felt necessary by the researcher that the students need to be taught about abortion- mainly focusing the unsafe abortion and its consequences so that the undergraduate students will be able to answer correctly.

Content validity of the tool

Content validity was done by 4 experts from the field of Obstetrics and Gynaecological Nursing and 1 expert in the field of community health nursing. The experts were requested to give their opinion in terms of the relevance, clarity and appropriateness of the items and necessary modification and simplification of the language were done.

Reliability of tool

The reliability was established by using Co-Variance Co-Efficient (Split half method formula) formula. The reliability of the tool was found to be 0.88 for knowledge questionnaire and 0.79 for attitude scale. The tool was found to be reliable.

Ethical Considertaion

Ethical clearance was obtained from the Institutional Ethics Committee, Army Institute of Nursing C/O 151 Base Hospital Guwahati, Assam.

Formal permission was taken from the Principals of Sankar Madhab College of Nursing, Guwahati, Assam, Rahman Institute of Nursing and Paramedics Sciences, Guwahati, Assam and CPMS College Of Nursing , Guwahati, Assam to conduct the study.

Informed written consent was taken from the study participants prior to data collection. Confidentiality and anonymity of the subjects were maintained throughout the study.

Statistics

The data obtained were organized, tabulated and interpreted by using descriptive and inferential statistics. The analysis of data were organized and interpreted under the following sections:

Section I: Descriptive analysis of Demographic variables.  

Table 1

Frequency and Percentage distribution of Demographic variables. N=100

Socio demographic variables

Frequency

Percentage

Age

19-20 years

58

58

21-22 years

36

36

23-24 years

36

6

Religion

Christian

32

32

Hindu

41

41

Muslim

24

24

Others

3

3

Educational status of mother

Illiterate

6

6

Primary school

7

7

Middle school

10

10

High School

21

21

Higher Secondary School

25

25

Graduate and above

31

31

Educational status of father

Illiterate

2

2

Primary school

3

3

Middle school

5

5

High School

14

14

Higher Secondary School

20

20

Graduate and above

56

56

Occupation of Mother

Unemployed

56

56

Daily Wager

6

6

Private Service

11

11

Govt. Service

27

27

Occupation of Father

Unemployed

6

6

Daily Wager

4

4

Private Service

37

37

Govt. Service

53

53

Type of Family

Nuclear Family

86

14

Joint Family

14

14

Area of residence

Urban

58

58

Rural

42

42

Source of information regarding abortion and its consequences

Health Personnel

29

29

Family

4

4

Friends

0

0

Mass media

50

50

No Information

17

17

Section II: Description of pre-test and post-test knowledge score regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students.

Table 2

Frequency and Percentage distribution of pre-test and post-test knowledge score regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students. N=100

Knowledge Score

Pre-test Score

Post-test Score

Frequency (f)

Percentage (%)

Frequency (f)

Percentage (%)

Inadequate knowledge (0-7)

75

75

0

0

Moderate knowledge (8-14)

25

25

39

39

Adequate knowledge (15-20)

0

0

61

61

Section III: Description of pre-test and post-test attitude score regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students.                        

Table 3

Frequency and percentage distribution of Pre-test and post-test attitude score regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate student. N=100   

Attitude Score

Pre-test Score

Post-test Score

Frequency

(f)

Percentage

(%)

Frequency

(f)

Percentage

(%)

Favorable attitude (31& Above)

54

54

97

97

Unfavorable attitude (Below 31)

46

46

3

3

Section IV: Description on effectiveness of structured teaching programme regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students.

Table 4

Comparison (Paired t-test) between Pre-test and Post-test knowledge score and attitude score regarding abortion and its consequences among undergraduate students. N=100

Knowledge

Score Range

Mean

SD

Mean Difference

T value

D f

P value

Remarks

Pre-test

1-12

6.22

2.227

8.67

27.27

99

0.001

S*

Post-test

10-20

14.89

2.445

Attitude

Pre-test

24-43

31.36

3.979

6.02

11.64

99

0.001

S*

Post-test

29-46

37.38

3.850

Section V: Analysis of association between pretest knowledge score and selected demographic variables of undergraduate students.

              

Table 5

Association between pretest knowledge with selected demographic variables of undergraduate students N=100

Demographic variables

Knowledge scores

χ2

Df

PValue

Remarks

Inadequate (0-7)

Moderately adequate (8-14)

Adequate (15-20)

Age in years

19-20

58

0

-

52.14

2

0.001

S*

21-22

17

19

-

23-24

0

6

-

Religion

Christian

17

15

-

Hindu

36

5

-

12.97

3

0.005

S*

Muslim

19

5

-

Others

3

0

-

Educational status of mother

Illiterate

3

3

-

Primary school

7

0

-

5.807

5

0.325

Middle school

9

1

-

High School Higher

15

6

-

Secondary School

18

7

-

Graduate and above

23

8

school High School

2

0

-

Higher Secondary

3

0

-

School Graduate and above

4

1

-

6.476

5

0.263

Educational status of father

-

Illiterate Primay

11

3

School Middle

11

9

Occupation of Mother

7.148

3

0.67

Unemployed

43

13

-

Daily Wager

2

4

-

Private Service

10

1

-

Govt. Service

20

7

-

Occupation of Father

Unemployed

6

0

-

7.095

3

0.069

Daily Wager

4

0

-

Private

23

14

-

Service Govt. Service

43

1

-

Type of Family

Nuclear

62

24

-

Family

-

2.769

1

0.096

Joint Family

13

1

Area of residence

Urban

43

15

-

0.055

1

0.815

Rural

32

10

Source of information regarding abortion and its consequens

-

-

18.5

3

0.001

S*

Health

14

15

Personnel Family

4

0

Friends

-

-

Mass media

45

5

No Informatin

12

5

Section VI: Analysis of association between pre-test attitude score and selected demographic variables of undergraduate students. 

Table 6

Association between pre-testattitude with selected demographic variables of undergraduate students. N=100 

Demographic variables

Attitude scores

χ2

Df

P-Value

Remarks

Favourable

(31&above)

Unfavourable

(Below 31)

Age

19-20

12

46

61.68

2

0.001

S*

21-22

36

0

23-24

6

0

Religion

Christian

23

9

17.14

3

0.001

S*

Hindu

12

29

Muslim

17

7

Others

2

1

Educational status of mother

13.92

5

0.016

S*

Illiterate

6

8

Primary school

2

5

Middle school

8

2

High School

10

11

Higher Secondary School

16

9

Graduate and above

12

19

Educational status of father

5.184

5

0.394

Illiterate

1

1

Primary school

1

2

Middle school

4

1

High School

10

4

Higher Secondary School

12

8

Graduate and above

26

30

Occupation of Mother

Unemployed

32

24

Daily Wager

5

1

3.617

3

0.306

Private Service

5

6

Govt.Service

12

15

Occupation of Father

Unemployed

4

2

Daily Wager

4

0

Private Service

21

16

4.904

3

0.179

Govt.Service

25

28

Type of Family

Nuclear Family

47

39

Joint Family

4

7

0.105

1

0.746

Area of residence

29

29

0.890

1

0.346

Urban

Rural

25

17

Source of information regarding abortion and Its consequences

8.552

3

0.036

S*

Health Personnel

22

7

Family

1

3

Friends

-

-

Mass media

23

27

No Information

8

9

Results

The result showed that, majority of participants -58% were in 19-20 years of age, 36% were in 21-22 years of age and 6% belongs to the age group of 23-24 years.

41% belongs to Hindu religion, 32% belongs to Christian religion, 24% belongs to Muslim religion and 3% belongs to other religion.

Majority of the participant’s mother -31% were graduate and above, 25% were educated up to Higher Secondary level, and 21% were educated till High school level, 10% had education up to Middle school, 7% had education up to primary school level and 6% were illiterate.

56% of the participant’s father were graduate and above, 20% were educated up to Higher Secondary level, as well as 14% were educated till High school level, 5% had education up to Middle school, 3% had education up to primary school level and only 2% were illiterate.

The result also showed that majority of the participant’s mothers - 56% were unemployed, 27% were in government service, 11% were in private service and 6% were daily wager.

Majority of the Participant’s fathers -53% were in government service, 37% were in private service, 4% were daily wager and 6% were unemployed. 86% participants were from nuclear family and 14% were from joint family.

58% were from urban area and 42% were from Rural areas.

50% Participants had their previous information regarding abortion and its consequences through mass media, 29% had Information from health personnel, 4% had information from family and 17% had no information.

The result showed that, in pre-test majority (75%) had inadequate knowledge and 25% had moderate knowledge where as in the post-test majority (61%) had adequate knowledge and 39% had moderate knowledge regarding abortion and its consequences

The result showed that, in pre-test majority of participants (54%) had favourable attitude and 46% had unfavourable attitude, where as in post-test majority (97%) had favourable attitude and only 3% had unfavourable attitude regarding abortion and its consequences.

The paired t test was carried out to examine the effectiveness of the structured teaching programme. In order to evaluate the effectiveness of structured teaching programme, the following null hypothesis was stated.

H01: There is no significant difference between the pre-test and post test knowledge scores among undergraduate students regarding abortion and its consequences.

The result showed that mean post-test knowledge score 14.89±2.445 was higher than mean pre-test knowledge score 6.22±2.227 with mean difference of 8.67. Pre-test and post-test mean knowledge score was compared by using paired t test which revealed that the calculated value (t=27.27, df=99, p=0.001) was highly significant. So, we have the evidence to accept research hypothesis (H1) and it reflects that the structured teaching programme was found effective. Hence, null (H01) Hypothesis is rejected.

The result also showed that mean post-test attitude score 37.38 ±3.850 was higher than mean pre-test attitude score 31.36 ±3.979 with mean difference of 6.02. Pre-test and post-test mean attitude score was compared by using paired t test which revealed that the calculated value (t=11.64, df=99, p=0.001)was highly significant. Hence, Structured teaching programme was effective in improving the attitude of undergraduate students regarding abortion and its consequences.

he resultrevealed that significant association was obtained between pre-test levels of knowledge score with age, religion and source of information of regarding abortion and its consequences among the undergraduate students at 0.05 level of significance (p<0.05).

Hence null hypothesis (H02) is rejected and research hypothesis (H2) is accepted with respect to age, religion, stream of studies, educational status of mother, educational status of father, occupation of mother, occupation of father, type of family, area of residence, source of information regarding abortion and its consequences.

The result showed that significant association was obtained between pre-test attitude score with selected demographic variables (age, religion, educational status of mother and source of information) at 0.05 level of significance (p<0.05).

Discussion

The study result showed that, majority of the participants (75%) had inadequate knowledge. The study finding is supported by the study findings conducted by Mekonnen Ataguadil, Awoke Zemnu (2020) on Assessment of Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Women of Reproductive Age Group Towards Abortion Care at Gambella Health Facilities, South West of Ethiopia which shows that out of 422 sampled women of reproductive age group (15-49 years of age), more than 30.5% of the respondents were having inadequate knowledge and lacking knowledge and had negative attitude towards induced abortion respectively.7

The study result showed that majority of participants (54%) had unfavourable attitude and 46% had favourable attitude regarding abortion and its consequences. The finding is supported by the study conducted by Yaecob R, Abera D and Meleko A (2018) on Knowledge, Attitude and Practice towards Induced Abortion and Associated Factors among Female students in Yebu Secondary School, South West Ethiopia where findings shows that more than 70% of the respondents were lacking knowledge and had negative attitude towards induced abortion.8

In the study result, the mean post-test knowledge score (14.89) was higher than mean pre-test knowledge score (6.22). The mean post-test attitude score (37.38) was higher than the mean pre-test attitude score (31.36). Thus, The result shows that the structured teaching programme was effective on knowledge and attitude regarding abortion and its consequences. The findings is supported by the study conducted by Moon H Shalini (2019) to assess the effectiveness of structured Teaching programme on the level of knowledge regarding Prevention of abortion among first-trimester pregnant Mother at selected maternity hospitals. The findings shows that the calculated 't' value was higher than the tabulated value at 5% level of significance which was statistically acceptable level of significance. In addition the calculated 'P' value for all the areas of knowledge regarding prevention of abortion among first-trimester pregnant mother was 0.000 which was ideal for any population. Hence it is statistically interpreted that the structured teaching programme on prevention of abortion among first-trimester pregnant mother was effective.9

The study result showed that, there was significant association between the pre-test knowledge score of the undergraduate students with selected demographic variables namely age (p=0.001), religion (p=0.005) and source of information regarding abortion and its consequences (p=0.001) at 0.05 level of significance (p<0.05). The study finding is supported by the study conducted by Abiola Abdul-Hakeem O,Oke Oluwabunmi A, Balogun Mobolanle R, Olatona Foluke A, Adegbesan- Omilabu Maymunah A (2016) on Knowledge, attitude, and practice of abortion among female students of two public senior secondary schools in Lagos Mainland Local Government Area, Lagos State. The study finding reveals that there was a statistically significant association (P = 0.004) between knowledge and the selected demographic variable i.e. ages regarding abortion.10

The study showed that, there was significant association between the pre-test attitude score with selected demographic variables namely age (0.001), religion (0.001), education status of mother (0.016) and source of information regarding abortion and its consequences (0.36) among the undergraduate students at 0.05 level of significance (p<0.05). The finding of the study contrast the study conducted by Tilahun F D and Misgun S M (2017) cross sectional study regarding Knowledge and attitude of women towards the legalization of abortion in the selected town of Ethiopia, Arba Minch town among Women of the reproductive age groups (15–49) and where it was found that educational status, marital status and having knowledge about the legalization of abortion were a statistically significant (P=0.001) association with the attitude.11

Conflict of Interest

None.

Source of Funding

None.

References

1 

D C Dutta Textbook of Obstetrics9/eJaypee2018151151https://www.jaypeebrothers.com/pgDetails.aspx?book_id=9789352702428

2 

The Medical Termination of Pregnancy (Amendment) Bill, 2020. PRSHealth and Family Welfare202015https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-medical-termination-of-pregnancy-amendment-bill-2020

3 

Anessafaultz How to Survive Unexpected Pregnancy While in College Successfully Continuing College While Having a Healthy Pregnancy2008http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/776827/how_to_survive_unexpected_pregnancy_pg3.html?cat=52

4 

M Ajitha Bengal records highest teen pregnancy casesOne World S Asia2010http://southasia.oneworld.net/todaysheadlines/india-bengal-records-highest-teen-pregnancy-cases#.UGnHvlF0Gcs

5 

International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) and ICFNational Fam Health Survey (NFHS-4)December 20171637

7 

Ataguadil Mekonnen Zemnu Awoke Assessment of Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Women of Reproductive Age Group Towards Abortion Care at Gambella Health Facilities, South West of EthiopiaInternational Journal of Biomedical Engineering and Clinical Science20206229292472-1298Science Publishing Grouphttps://dx.doi.org/10.11648/j.ijbecs.20200602.12

8 

Asrat Meleko Knowledge, Attitude and Practice towards Induced Abortion and Associated Factors among Female students in Yebu Secondary School, Jimma zone, South West EthiopiaGlobal Journal of Reproductive Medicine2018522575-8594Juniper Publishershttps://dx.doi.org/10.19080/gjorm.2018.05.555659

9 

Shalini H Moon A STUDY TO ASSESS THE EFFECTIVENESS OF STRUCTURED TEACHING PROGRAMME ON THE LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE REGARDING PREVENTION OF ABORTION AMONG FIRST-TRIMESTER PREGNANT MOTHER AT SELECTED MATERNITY HOSPITALSindian J appl Res201997567

10 

A Hakeem A Oke M R Balogun F A Olatona M A Omilabu Knowledge, attitude, and practice of abortion among female students of two public senior secondary schools in Lagos Mainland Local Government Area, Lagos StateJ Clinicls sci2016132827Lagos Statehttps://dx.doi.org/10.4103/2408-7408.179682

11 

T F Debela M S Mekuria Knowledge and attitude of women towards the legalization of abortion in the selected town of EthiopiaReprod Health20181519https://reproductive-health-journal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12978-018-0634-0



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 18-02-2021

Accepted : 10-03-2021


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/ 10.18231/j.ijpns.2021.002


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 3043

PDF Downloaded: 1152